grammar - Has or Have +had in one sentence?


    This question already has an answer here:

  • Answers
    Know someone who can answer? Share a link to this question via email, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook.

    Related Question

    grammar - Are these garden path sentences grammatically correct?
  • ErikE


    A garden path sentence is one that is exceptionally hard for the reader to parse. English is especially prone to this because it is an analytical language and so many words can be many different parts of speech. I read that as a person reads a sentence, he builds up a likely meaning for each word and a meaning for the whole sentence word by word, then if a "disambiguating word" appears that changes the meaning, he switches to the new meaning and continues. When the disambiguating word is far away from the ambiguous word, the sentence can be very difficult to understand.

    The classic garden path sentence, as far as I am aware, is "The horse raced past the barn fell." The ambiguous word is raced and the disambiguating word is fell. For those who don't think this is a perfectly grammatical sentence, the meaning is the same as "The horse [that was] raced past the barn fell." Or perhaps more clearly using a different word, "The horse driven past the barn fell."

    Before I ask my question, since these things are so cool (to me, anyway), here are a few more examples:

    • The old man the boats.
    • While Anna dressed the baby spit up on the bed.
    • The man returned to his house was happy.
    • Fat people eat accumulates.
    • She told me a little white lie will come back to haunt me.
    • We painted the wall with cracks.

    The Question – My Own Garden Path Sentence

    After enjoying these and many other garden path sentences I read about, I invented one of my own. Recently I told it to a friend, but he didn't really get my example garden path sentences (the horse, the old, and Anna) and argued that they and mine were not correct grammar. So I submit it to you for your analysis:

    The men run through the arches screamed.

    As explanation, the men were stabbed in the feet, possibly as a form of torture.

    I swear I had several others I invented five to ten years ago, but I can't remember them. Perhaps I will invent some new ones.

    Is that sentence correct grammar? As well as the others?

    Feel free to edit my grammar. No comment necessary.

  • Related Answers
    Know someone who can answer? Share a link to this question via email, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook.